I like the Aldo ones much better. The cloth just comes up too far on the foot in the first pair you posted and I think it'll make your legs look shorter, especially when combined with the black ankle tie. I think the Tommy Hilfiger, JCrew or Aldo ones are all much better options.
CarrieS, did you check shoebuy.com? I got them for $35 with first time customer discount and a code. I don't know what size you are, but they still have them in sizes 7-11.
CarrieS, did you check shoebuy.com? I got them for $35 with first time customer discount and a code. I don't know what size you are, but they still have them in sizes 7-11.
I did check there, but I'm a 5-5.5 shoe, so those would be too big