Am I being blinded by the price($140)? I love dramatic shoes (about the only crazy thing I can really get away with in my field), and these certainly qualify.
I don't like the return policy(merch credit only), otherwise, I would buy them to try them on...
actually, i think those are really great! i have otk boots and really like them. (for the record i am 5'2")
i'll try to take a picture of me in them so you can see if they further dwarf the shorties!
ok, you seem decided maybe, but if you change your mind! here are mine:
i couldn't find my black skirt, but this would definitely look better monochromatic and wouldn't shorten me as much, but i still even like them with this mini! if you don't want to spend so much, you could always find them on ebay. (which is where i got mine, vintage, for about $60) mine are slouchy and have a 2" heel. i really like the ones you posted, though, because they seem more streamlined. i just can't rationalize two pairs of otk boots. (unless i, ahem, change professions!)