i voted for the batignolles horizontal , but i like the vertical, too. the just-plain-batignolles looks like you won't be able to sling it over your shoulder and the coussin kinda looks like a cushion
i also like the batignolles horizontal the most... i also suggest going to yr lv store and trying them out.. i know i went in for one bag and left w/ a different one!
Thanx for the input so far. I think I'll go w/ either 1 or 3. I'm kinda feeling the vertical one more because I'm thinking the horizontal might be too big. But I'll go to the store and compare them before deciding.