I bought a pair of 1.5 inch wedge sandals, and I swam in the size 11 (my normal size for closed toe). I ordered the 10 and they are kinda small, but still wearable. Especailly after they stretch.
Maybe order 8.5 and use foot petals?
__________________
Veni, Vedi, Visa.
I came, I saw, I did a little shopping.
I just got my Dolce Vita peeptoe wedges tonight. They run a bit large but I'm going to wear them with tights so I think they'll be fine. The overall fit is great for my slightly wider feet - so comfy!