They are definitely a NO. I'm returning them. They just look really cheap, there's an odd stud on the side, and the material is crap. Nothing like the picture online.
I ordered these from Nordie's by phone from a store because they're sold out online and got them yesterday! I love them! They're so cute and comfy. The material is calf hair and leather. I ordered a size 6 1/2, but sometimes I wear a 7 and these fit me just right. I was worried about them being wide because I have narrow feet, but they aren't at all. HTH!