STYLETHREAD -- LET'S TALK SHOP!

twinkle · Coach

Taylor or Katharine - poll

Kitty · Hermes

I don't like either of them....

Luv2Shop · Kate Spade

Neither. I will buy Chris's album the minute it comes out. I am not the least bit interested in these two. If I had to pick I would say Taylor, because I like Kelly Clarkson and we don't need a 1/2 ass version of her out there, ie Katharine

JoceyBaby23 · Gucci

I dont like either. I was routing for Chris and Elliott.

I chose Kat only because I really dislike Taylor.

Drew · Gucci

Ok, so far so NOT good. According to the poll where it's at right now with 9 votes McPhee is in the lead by 11.2 points! Come on, STer's give Taylor more support! I would totally buy tickets to a live performance of his, not sure about a CD though...

ayo · Coach

Really? Taylor is a diva? I totally can't see that he just looks so corny and nice..

that's too bad..I like him better still..Katharine annoys me..

Now that Chris...mm mm mm...that is one hot sexy man, and oh yeah he can sing to ...I would def buy he's album

twinkle · Coach

agree with you guys - Chris totally should have won and i expect him to be the most commercially successful...

member · Hermes

Neither. Chris should have won. I find Taylor obnoxious and annoying and I don't really see him as talented. Kat is just another Kelly Clarkson pop singer, which is why she will probably win.

sephorablue · Marc Jacobs

aw, no love for Taylor! I actually think Chris is kind of a generic singer, whereas Taylor's voice has character, I think. I definitely liked Chris but I didn't think he was the best. Katharine-meh.

rar210 · Marc Jacobs

I was a BIG Chris fan. I actually chose he and Taylor from there auditions. Since Chris is out of the running - I hope Taylor pulls through!

Claudia · Gucci

I love both. I think Katherine is gorgeous and has a really nice voice. I also like Taylor because he has a great voice too and is pretty entertaining. I can't vote, because I can't make up my mind.

wicked · Coach

I voted for Taylor, but I thought his cover of "Living for the City" was a huge disgrace! I do think Taylor has more personality than Katherine.

theotherjess · Chanel

I say Katharine but only because she's a friend of a friend. I don't even watch AI...I'm a Lost girl

.

daiz519 · Dooney & Bourke

Mara--ditto on the nasty things about Taylor from an inside source. My vote goes to Katharine but I wasn't at all excited about any of the songs either of them sang last night. I wanted to hear them sing new songs...not ones they have previously sang. And the new ones written for them were just plain boring.

subwolley · Kate Spade

I thought everyone this season was horrible, I didn't like anyone. But between the two, I think Taylor. I don't like Kathrine, she doesn't really have any personality singing-wise.

Prissy · Dooney & Bourke

I really wanted Chris to win. His voice is awesome.

berryahou35 · Dooney & Bourke

I wanted Elliot!