STYLETHREAD -- LET'S TALK SHOP!

member · Hermes

American Idol - Anyone Else Still Watching?

blubirde · Chanel

I don't really keep up, except via radio bits about AI but I caught a bit of it last night. I am so sick of Ace! I think I saw him in the very first episode of the top 12 and thought he was sooo cute but now I just cringe everytime I see him. Hopefully he's out.

I also saw Katherine McPhee and while I thought Someone to Watch Over Me requires a lot more emotion than she put into it, I thought her voice was great. So I hope she stays.

I don't really know the rest but there's my two cents, fwiw.

sweater girl · BCBG

I'm still watching...although I'm not really thrilled with any of them...my thoughts:

From the beginning I liked Chris and Taylor but I'm kind of getting bored with them...

Katherine has a beautiful voice but zero personality.

Paris has been great some weeks but also some not so great weeks...not sure if it is her age or what?

Elliot is kind of growing on me

Ace and Kelly totally have to go...I can't stand either of them...he's such a tool and the dumb blonde routine is annoying.

-- Edited by sweater girl at 12:39, 2006-04-19

-- Edited by sweater girl at 13:04, 2006-04-19

-- Edited by sweater girl at 14:29, 2006-04-19

Claudia · Gucci

I didn't get to watch last night, because I went to a play. My favorite is Katherine! I love her!

valenciana · Dooney & Bourke

i pretty much agree with everyone else...Ace is obnoxious, cute yes, but annoying as hell. and his singing isn't fantastic. he peaked with Father Figure, IMO. and yeah, Taylor's schtick is getting old too.

Kellie has GOT to go. but she won't, at least not yet.

i have not really been that excited with anyone, but Elliot is starting to grow on me. i think he might be my favorite, i also like that he just seems pretty down to earth. but i think he's gonna go tonight. (not that i voted or anything, so i guess i can't really be too sad)

i predict Katherine and Chris for the top 2.

RyanJ · Coach

My mom and I are

Katherine drives me crazy. I would have hated her if we went to highschool together. "I am pretty and have a good voice, so there is not need for me to have a personality"

Ace is so skeezy. I am sure after the show he hits on 16 year old girls.

I want Taylor to win and my mom likes Chirs.

Kellie doens't really bother me because I think she really is an idiot, and not an act. I think she would probalby be a very nice person.

Elliott is growing on me too. In the beginning of the show I wasn't a big fan of him, but I kind of like him now.

Paris is just kind of there. Don't have her, don't love her.

-- Edited by RyanJ at 15:57, 2006-04-19

nunzi182 · Kate Spade

I cringe everything I see the following people on stage because I can't stand them.at.all.

-Ace
-Taylor
-Paris
-Kelly
-Chris

That doesn't leave too many. I love Elliott and Katherine. They are my favorites and once either of them gets kicked off I'll probably stop watching until next season.

Ace really is annoying.

Tati · Chanel

RyanJ wrote:

Katherine drives me crazy. I would have hated her if we went to highschool together. "I am pretty and have a good voice, so there is not need for me to have a personality" -- Edited by RyanJ at 15:57, 2006-04-19

thats exactly how i feel about her too!

i've always liked Elliot, that boy can sing,i wouldn't mind if he won...... i really dont have a favorite like i've had in the past seasons.

Cortney1982 · Chanel

I hated Ace from Day one. Didn't he look a lot like Kevin Ferderline with his hair slicked back!

Kelli's dumb blondness is getting annoying. I thought it was terrible of her to admit she was a horrible singer. Don't get yourself voted off, maybe she is an idiot!

Taylor Hicks is alright. My family loves him, they call him Taylor Ticks!

Elliot is much better than I thought, hopefully he won't go home tonight.

Katherine- Well, the sweet thing worked for Kelly Clarkson but maybe not this season.

Paris- Hmm..seems like we don't know too much about her, I just don't like her singing pop songs, last night suited her better.

Chris- I guess he can sing and not scream. I was surprised he could do other stuff!

Cortney1982 · Chanel

Yeah, Ace got the boot!

travelgirl · Kate Spade

I so love Elliott! Can we all pitch in and vote for him? Please???

JoceyBaby23 · Gucci

My favorites are Elliott, Katherine, and Chris.

Kelly and Taylor will be the next to go.. IMO.

valenciana · Dooney & Bourke

JoceyBaby23 wrote:

Kelly and Taylor will be the next to go.. IMO.

I definitely think they *should* be the next ones to go...but they are the only two left who have never been in the bottom 3...

Unless he totally messes up, I'm officially in the Elliot camp. I might even break out the phone and vote this week.