I tried on this one- It is not opaque like in the pic- it is actually sheer enough that you would have to wear a tank top underneath. It is cute irl and runs tts. Reminds me of something I'd see at Anthro. It has sort of a rounded peter pan collar, and there are actually eyelet cutouts on the back of the shirt too if I remember correctly. It was really flattering on- I was all set to get it when I discovered an ink stain in the back of the shirt and it was the only shirt the store had, so I'm probably just going to order it online. Haven't seen the 2nd shirt- I think it's only available online. It looks cute though.