So although I LOVE both pairs.. I have having serious guilt and think I should return one of these and (if anything) get another pair of pumps that I can actually wear to work.
1. Do you think they are too similar? Both with the wood soles and grommets?
I would keep the 1st pair. You wear mostly black- tan and black look really great together. Also, they will be really versitale ( i can't spell today) with spring whites, pinks, etc.