I vote for option #2, whenever I try to wear a big top with skinny jeans I look like a pirate, and those boots are even sort of pirate-style, so I think it would just be too much.
__________________
"...If I know my supermodels (and according to the half-dozen or so draped across my bed in a jenga of crack-glazed longing, I certainly do)"
I vote for option #2, whenever I try to wear a big top with skinny jeans I look like a pirate, and those boots are even sort of pirate-style, so I think it would just be too much.
I agree.
__________________
Bad taste is like a nice dash of paprika. We all could use more of it. It's no taste I'm against. -Diana Vreeland
I voted for #1 because the proportions just don't look right to me to have a dress and bootcut jeans on at the same time. I think a dress and skinnier jeans looks much better.
But that being said, I'm not sure I'd tuck the jeans into the boots. I think heels would be better at keeping the bottom part of the outfit lighter/slimmer.