"Deep down you may still be that same great guy I used to know. But it's not who you are underneath, it's what you do that defines you" Rachel Dawes, Batman Begins
I much prefer the first ones, but maybe I'm biased because I have the pink Burberry ones. But I think they're much more timeless than the moonboots (which were in last year and will be in this year-- but will probably be a bit last year by next year). Also, the Burberry ones can be worn all year (although in the snow you'll need warm socks to go with them) while the moon boots are for snow.
well I would go with #1 if you want cute and practical rain boots. I love all things pucci but i can't see moonboots serving the same purpose of rainboots so I would pass on them if you want a true rain boot.