#2 looks so cozy! If it's as soft as it looks, I think that's a great price- you could literally wear it like once a week all winter! #1 I think is too expensive and I'm not crazy about the sleeves on #3 but it is a good price depending on the fit...looks like it might pill easily though.
I'm going to buy #2 myself, so I definitely think that it's worth the price. I don't know if #1 is worth $88 though I could see you wearing it. Maybe wait for it to go on sale?