It depends what you're looking for. If you want something for cold weather, I'd get the BCBG one. My mom has the Burberry one... it's super cute but not too warm. It would be a better coat for fall.
I usually buy a fall coat and that's it. I don't spend much time outside in the winter and when I do, I would rather just wear layers of clothes under a lighter coat. I hate to have a big bulky coat. So, judge on looks only. :)