I vote for the MJ because I despise all things LV since I see fakes all the time and I don't even live in a fashionable city. I also hate all things brown and that bag is just brown and boring to me.
I loved the MJ one from your other post and think that it will last you for years also. I don't think that it is overly trendy and will date you so you couldn't use it in years to come.