I bought these because mine are so old, and I have a replacement pair, but now I have replacements for the replacement pair:
and these:
I love them! They are so comfy- my whale flips are my comfiest flip flops- they beat my Reefs even. I'm not the preppiest girl but, like my surfer girl flats, I like to pay homage to my roots in my preppy hometown (Annapolis). I got them both for $39.50 shipped, using LUCKYMAG to get 25% off. They are normally $40 a pair, pricey, but def. worth it for $20 a pair! These are my favorite flip flops ever! I've only tried the preppy trim flip flops (I wear between a 9 and 10 in shoes and the 10 fits best in these so size up) so I can't vouch for all of her styles.