i use jojoba oil on a cotton pad -- works great and is non-irritating.
I've used that before too and really like it, especially cause its real cheap. But right now I'm using Kiehls and really love theirs too! I've used cheap and other expensive brands and these two I really like.
I am obsessed with Nivea Visage Eye Make-up Remover. It's about $6 and you can get it at Walmart, Target, ect. I've been using it for as long as I can remember. It gets waterproof mascara off without leaving that nasty, greasy residue that so many make-up removers leave behind.
i use L'Oreal (i think) its in a blue/clear bottle and you can get it at Walmart, Target, etc. i don't use waterproof mascara so i don't know how well it gets that off though...
It's by Avon and it's called Moisture Effective Eye Makeup Remover lotion. It's only $4/bottle and it's awesome! It's really gentle and not greasy at all.
this is my favorite. i bought it and have since seen it featured in several magazines. I feel like i could dump the whole bottle in my eye and it wouldn't hurt. it's not greasy at all!
I've also found some great ones in the whole foods beauty department. I feel like with eye make up remover, i want organic!
__________________
"i tell you one lesson I learned
If you want to be something in life, You ain't gonna get it unless, You give a little bit of sacrifice, Oohh, sometimes before you smile you got to cry.." -The Roots
I have VERY sensitive skin and eyes, they're always irritated. My favorite in the drugstore brands is by Loreal and its in a little blue botte w/white cap.
also, when I have nothing else, a litte Aquaphor rubbed on and wiped off with a damp tissue does the trick!
I haven't really had a fave until now. I was visiting my friend in San Diego and I used what she had. It's called Going, Going, Gone by Ultima II and they are the green tea and chamomile eye swipes. The container has 100 swipes and it cost about $8.50 I think. I LOVE these things!!! I got them at Ulta.
I've tried most of the ones the girls listed and my favorite (of all time) is the Rimmel brand. You can get it at Wal-Mart. (I boycott Walmart so I get my grandmother to get it for me. I know it's cheating!) I use it alllllll the time. I use it to take off a little here and there when I misapply something and to take off my black, smokey eye with waterproof mascara. It's really gentle on your eyes and leaves no residue at all. It has a consistency of water but is gentler on your eyes, if it gets in them, than water.
I haven't been to Ulta lately but maybe you could get it there also since they started selling Rimmel products? Walgreens sells Rimmel too but I haven't found the eye makeup remover yet.
I love Mary Kay as well, but I found a really cheap remover that is oil free at the drugstore. It is the Maybelienne brand Oil Free eye make up remover. It's usually about $4.50. Make sure you get the blue bottle and not the pink because pink has oil in it and it is so greasy on my face. The oil free one is awesome!!!