I recently bought a 4g 20gig iPod and I can't decide on a case. I've been looking at the more clear ones, because I like the look of the iPod's sleek design. But I really want to protect it against scratches. I've been reading about many of the silicone/rubber ones attracting dirt and hair... I've been looking at this one, and others similar....
I was at the Apple store and the salesgirl told me she highly recommends a "flip" leather case because they are the sturdiest and also protect the screen of the ipod. They had them only in black for $29.95, but good thing I didn't buy it because I got a pink leather one from ebay for only $9.95
I already posted this but the guy's ebay store is here:
I don't know which would be best but Budget Living has a great spread on ipod cases right now. You should check it out. They are really, really cute and as soon as I have my xmas ipod, I'm going to purchase at least one listed. I love Budget Living but it has too much ad space and not enough content.