i like them, i like the way they could contrast w/an otherwise girly outfit. i also like that they are built w/a specific functionality in mind, as opposed to something that's just supposed to look good.
Everyone in my town wears these: Highschool and college age girls who wear them with khaki shorts and sorority t-shirts. They alternate between these and crocs in their sorority/college colors. They get on my nerves because it is all I see, but I have seen them look cute the way lynnie described--with girlier outfits. My sister wears them with jeans and an antique lacy top and that looks pretty cute.
__________________
Know first, who you are; and then adorn yourself accordingly.
-Epictetus
I'm not really a fan. I know a lot of college age girls in the South wear them a lot in the summer, but I've never really liked the look. They're fine for being on a boat and whatnot, but other than that, they tend to look sloppy.