I have the first sweater you posted, and I had to size down. I'd normally wear a size S at Gap and I needed an XS, so if you're an XS - go w/that size. I tried it on over a long sleeve button down shirt, and had plenty of room.
I wouldn't size up - I think they're TTS, but others have sized down. So, definitely don't size up.
I should warn that the first sweater vest sheds like crazy...so, I'd recommend getting it in gray. I bought it in black, but after wearing it around the house w/ a white button-up under it the white shirt was COVERED in hairs.
Kitty wrote: I wouldn't size up - I think they're TTS, but others have sized down. So, definitely don't size up. I should warn that the first sweater vest sheds like crazy...so, I'd recommend getting it in gray. I bought it in black, but after wearing it around the house w/ a white button-up under it the white shirt was COVERED in hairs.
Yep - I agree, I'd get the gray. I have the gray and the shedding isn't very noticeable since it's a light color. HTH!