STYLETHREAD -- LET'S TALK SHOP!

atlgirl · Gucci

Favorite Waterproof Mascara

member · Hermes

I cannot say enough good things about this:

Shu Uemera Mascara Basic.

It's waterproof and it's the ONLY mascara I've ever tried that does not flake or clump. I highly recommend.

HeatherLynn · Gucci

I love Dior Show. It is best mascara I have ever tried.

Aurora · Marc Jacobs

it depends on the look you are going for. I have tried both the she uerma one and the dior show. I prefer dior for the dark black color but she uerma is a more natural look for me. Both are nice though.

member · Hermes

Aurora wrote:

it depends on the look you are going for. I have tried both the she uerma one and the dior show. I prefer dior for the dark black color but she uerma is a more natural look for me. Both are nice though.

If I put two coats of the Shu on, I get just as dark of lashes as I did w/Diorshow. That's JMO.

greendiamond · Marc Jacobs

I used Dior Show waterproof and it rubbed off on my under eye. I am currently trying Kanebo 38 degree lengthening mascara. It stays on great, but doesn't build my lashes like Dior Show did. I also like Lancome for waterproof. It won't budge, but I bought the wrong formula, so I used it to coat my Dior Show lashes on special occasions.

-gd

Lilykind · Hermes

I second the Shu Uemera. Best. Mascara. Ever.

All others look like crap compared to it.

atlgirl · Gucci

Thank you, ladies! I knew y'all would have some good recs.

It looks like I am going to have to try both and figure out which I prefer. :)

dot · Marc Jacobs

i LOVE kanebo 38 degree waterproof mascara. better than shu in my opinion. dior show i didn't like the brush and it also smeared on me.

i have greasy lids and get smudges under my eyes ALL the time. this is the only mascara i have found that doesn't smudge. i would say shu basic is a good second but in the summer especially this is the only one i will use. it's expensive $30, but it's highly worth it for me.

it also comes off easily with soap and water. i have swam in pools and the ocean with this on and no smudging or smearing. i have used this mascara faithfully for over a year now.. which is highly unusual for a beauty product junkie like myself. definitely try it!!!

PrincessPink · BCBG

Hi All,
I gotta say I am a big fan of Trish McEvoy. It goes on, stays on, then comes right off with a little soap and water and leaves NO under-eye residue... I'm a convert.