STYLETHREAD -- LET'S TALK SHOP!

Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: TV's obsession with housewives


Hermes

Status: Offline
Posts: 6400
Date:
TV's obsession with housewives
Permalink Closed


This is an interesting commentary on a trend I've been noticing for a while. I have many female students who would like nothing more than to be Gabrielle from DH for the rest of their lives. It's disturbing to me, esp. because they aren't even idealizing the 50's homemaker image -- it's the vapid, empty existence they want.


link

Real Wife Desperate housewives, wife-swappers, and the women of Bravo.By Troy Patterson
Posted Tuesday, March 21, 2006, at 6:27 PM ET


Kim Bryant from Real Housewives of Orange County. Click image to expand.

Kim Bryant from Real Housewives of Orange County

Wives are hot right now. During Sex and the City's original run, its Carrie Bradshaw, an urban bachelorette, was television's symbolic woman. After Carrie toddled away in 2004, the dames of ABC's cunningly polished soap opera Desperate Housewives replaced her at the center of pop-cultural female fantasy. The show became a hit not just because it was funny and foxy; it lucked into a moment when the audience was hungry for domestic cheese. For whatever reason, the tube is now popping with tales focused on wifedom—burlesques of matrimony, parables of housekeeping, and lazy daydreams of back-door men.


Both Wife Swap (ABC)—it isn't what it sounds like, but can a swingers reality show really be so far away?—and the identically themed Trading Spouses (Fox) beat Desperate Housewives to the air by a few months and both are still going strong. Monday night on Wife Swap, a fitness nut and a woman raising her kids to be pleasant sloths switched homes for two weeks. It was, as usual, a hoot. The show encourages you to reflect on parenting, and whoever it is that puts together the soundtrack would seem to have both an excellent sense of humor and a grudging respect for Burt Bacharach.


Meanwhile, Footballers Wive$ (BBC America), sleazy from that dollar sign on down, has garnered itself an impressive amount of ink on the occasion of its third-season premiere. And why not? The show, set in the British soccer world, carefully explores a well-chosen set of themes—kinky sex, blind greed, dumb rage, trashy hairdos, and catfights choreographed with the utmost sophistication. Its sensibility is less soap-operatic than tabloid, and its main minx, played by an actress named Zoe Lucker, is possessed of a delicious snarl.


Such is the climate into which the reality show The Real Housewives of Orange County (Bravo, Tuesdays at 10 p.m. ET) breezes this week. The raw material of its seven episodes comes from the lives of four women who live within a gated community called Coto de Caza and another, a divorcée, who has been cast out of that paradise. "This isn't just a place to live—it's a lifestyle," one of them says tonight, telling you all you need to know.

Jeana Keough is a former Playboy Playmate married to a former professional baseball player who took her as his bride in a kind of eugenics experiment: "My husband and his mother picked me out of several of his girlfriends because they thought I had the right build for their genetics." Jeana sells real estate. Kimberly Bryant has two perfectly lovely children and two perfectly spherical breasts. Jo De La Rosa is 24, which makes her nearly a generation younger than the other wives. Since moving in with her fiancé, she has become a "lady of leisure," which mostly involves moping around a McMansion in big fuzzy slippers. When not running a lucrative insurance brokerage, Vicki Gunvalson is busy living vicariously through her two teenagers. Vicki employs Lauri Waring, the wife who has fallen from grace. It says here in the press notes that the third episode will find Vicki and Lauri getting a home treatment of Botox in preparation for a big convention.


While Botox jokes are hardly fresh, they're clearly part of the story here, and Real Housewives strives to be comprehensive. Here is a craftily presented slice of America that makes room for guns, silicone, status anxiety, and sibling rivalry. The show's surface joys are identical to those of MTV's My Super Sweet 16—resentment mingles with superiority, and tasteless people conspicuously consume. But what makes the show something better than a guilty pleasure is the way that, after introducing its subjects as borderline-reprehensible cartoons, it allows them flickers of self-awareness or shows them trying their damnedest to be terrific parents. In other words, you can catch these wives being human in the moments when they're not simply playing house.  



-- Edited by halleybird at 21:22, 2006-03-22

__________________
"We live in an age where unnecessary things are our only necessities." --Oscar Wilde


Chanel

Status: Offline
Posts: 4845
Date:
Permalink Closed

I know what you mean. I wonder where all this talk of being a SAHM comes from? Of course it's fine and all that, but it seems like all of a sudden, it's what every woman wants. When did that happen? When we were little, we all wanted to be astronauts or teachers or something like that. I wonder what the point is where "what I want to be when I grow up" stops being a career and starts being more domestic?


I wonder if men ever get mad that women have this option available to them and men don't? Of course it can work out that way, but it's rare and it's not as acceptable as it is for women.


It's a curious topic and I'm always intrigued by everyone's response to it. That said, I've seen the Real Wives of the OC and I'm slightly addicted to it already. It's crazy! But what strikes me about the show is the desperation of the women. They are desperate to keep up the status quo and desperate to keep their husbands happy. There was one wife who started randomly crying and obsessing about losing her husband. (He asked her to get a boob job once she started looking old.) I look forward to the day when my financial burdens will be lessened slightly by the addition of an income but I could never imagine myself being dependent on someone else's income to buy groceries, much less support my shopping habit.



__________________
http://dailypointers.blogspot.com/


Hermes

Status: Offline
Posts: 6400
Date:
Permalink Closed

I don't get it either, blubirde, but this is definitely a different generation. And what bothers me is NOT the part about not having a job -- it's that the girls I know think growing up=marrying someone rich, shopping all day, and laying by the pool. When I was in HS, none of my friends would have dreamed of such a thing.


There are plenty of stay-at-home wives/girlfriends here, on this forum, who still lead very fulfilling lives, but these girls want nothing of the sort: no classes, businesses, children or hobbies to get in the way. I hope it's just a temporary thing.



__________________
"We live in an age where unnecessary things are our only necessities." --Oscar Wilde


Kate Spade

Status: Offline
Posts: 1425
Date:
Permalink Closed

I think it was leah leanna who it it on the head in another post.  She said she calls the current generation of kids "The Entitlement Generation."  My guess is a lot of the yougner girls want someone to provide for them without having to give something back.  Instead of making the transition to self-sufficient adulthood, they want to move from having parent-as-caretaker to husband-as-caretaker.  TV depicts being a housewife as an easy, chore-free, responsibility-free existence.  They want a man who will buy them nice things.


I think younger girls today don't want responsibility.  Maybe parents today aren't encouraging responsibility.  It seems like a lot of pre teens and teens do have everything handed to them, and expect that life will be that way forever.  I think that college would help them get over it.


Also, I think a lot of the TV shows and the cult of celebrity in this country glorifies a superficial existence.  More so than it did when I was a teenager (I'm 27 now). Maybe I'm out of it, but doesn't it seem like the teen idols (Lindsay Lohan & Co., and Paris Hilton) are terrible role models that perpetuate the idea of a shallow, superficial existence?  I mean, Paris Hilton is famous just because she's rich.  She doesn't *do* anything.  And young girls look up to her. 


I would hope it's temporary, and that once they learn more about what real life is like, they'll grow out of it. 



__________________


Hermes

Status: Offline
Posts: 5131
Date:
Permalink Closed

I have no idea either, and while I see absolutely nothing wrong with being a SAHM (hey, I wouldn't pass up the opportunity!), I can't imagine never dreaming of having more than that! Even if I was staying home, I'm sure I would have some sort of small business of my own (for fun) and would take classes, etc. Not just lay around all day eating bon-bons!


When I was in high school, I had all sorts of huge dreams for myself. I was going to go to cornell and study medicine or law and be super sucessful. I wanted to run for office. I don't think there was anything that I DIDN'T want to do! Now my sister is a sophomore in HS and is the total opposite. She has no desire to go to college. She has no desire to work and has never even considered a summer job (I started working in a library when I was 14- I wanted the money and the responsability- plus it was fun!). When we ask her what she wants to do her answer is "get married and have kids." That scares me! Especially since she's homeschooled and almost all of her social interaction is through dance (not exactly a ton of guys!) so I have no idea where she thinks she's going to meet this guy that has the money and desire to marry her and let her do nothing!  Meanwhile se has basically no marketable skills, probably wouldn't do anything at work if she had a job, and I  can see her just living with my parents for the rest of her life because she has no other option. I don't know...but its scary!



__________________
"Life's too short to wear ugly shoes."

My recipe blog: healthy-delicious.com


Chanel

Status: Offline
Posts: 3197
Date:
Permalink Closed

that's funny you bring this up.  a couple of months ago there was a story on the local news about this.  it interviewed younger girls and women just graduating college and a lot of them voiced this same desire. 


my bf and i saw the real housewives of orange county and we were laughing at how ridiculous it is. 


i guess watching it i felt super lucky that i had such a great female role model in my life.  my mom taught me that i can have my cake and eat it too.  i just wish that younger generations would realize that you can have both.  you just have to be creative. 


i know i've said this before, but my mom worked and had kids and we never saw a day care center.  that's part of the reason why i chose to go into nursing.  my mom worked nights (part time when we were little) as a nurse, and now works full time.  she has a great fullfilling career and well-adjusted kids.  i know that nursing is not for everyone, but it's a great option, especially since you can do so much with a nursing degree (do nursing law, teach, work at different kinds of clinics...).  heck, i'm entertaining the idea of working at a laser hair removal place part time so that i can have it all (ok, never having to shave isn't having it all, but it's a step closer ). 


i think we just need to teach kids how to be creative about it. 



__________________
"i tell you one lesson I learned If you want to be something in life, You ain't gonna get it unless, You give a little bit of sacrifice, Oohh, sometimes before you smile you got to cry.." -The Roots
jj


Kate Spade

Status: Offline
Posts: 1212
Date:
Permalink Closed

I never really thought of anyone actually aspiring to be a desperate housewife - scary!  What's wrong with these people??


I just think the whole housewives-TV show thing is a trend that will pass.  Desperate Housewives = fabulous ratings and tons of money for advertisers, so now every network is doing their own version.  It's just like the reality TV craze.  I watched Dynasty/Dallas/Knots Landing growing up, and I didn't aspire to be a heartless business person, living in a mansion with my entire family.



__________________


Kenneth Cole

Status: Offline
Posts: 423
Date:
Permalink Closed

There's a facebook group at my school called "Can't I Just Major in How to Be a Good Housewife?"

And I quote..."Who needs Psychology, English, Criminal Justice, Technology, Communications, or any other crazy majors when we just want to bake cookies and love our future husbands all day!"

It drives me crazy. Why are you wasting all this money to have a college degree when you will never use it? Are you really just going to school to find someone to marry??

I have nothing against SAHMs, but it's one thing to decide in your late 20s or 30s, and another to have that plan before even going to college. Really, what's it for? And do your parents know?

__________________


Coach

Status: Offline
Posts: 1915
Date:
Permalink Closed

Shello wrote:



There's a facebook group at my school called "Can't I Just Major in How to Be a Good Housewife?" And I quote..."Who needs Psychology, English, Criminal Justice, Technology, Communications, or any other crazy majors when we just want to bake cookies and love our future husbands all day!" It drives me crazy. Why are you wasting all this money to have a college degree when you will never use it? Are you really just going to school to find someone to marry?? I have nothing against SAHMs, but it's one thing to decide in your late 20s or 30s, and another to have that plan before even going to college. Really, what's it for? And do your parents know?



I don't see the problem w/ a woman going to college and not using their education. You never know when you may need an education. If you get divorced  or if the husband dies. Most of the women in my family are educated and most of them choose not to work. My mom is one of the very few that works. She doesn't have too and I can see in a few years her not working anymore. The cost for her to malpractice insurance is so freakin ridicoulous- but that is a different topic.


I also think that it depends on how you view "not using your education". Maybe I won't get a job where I use my business degree, but I have learned so many things in college.  I went to college because I wanted a college education. I love to learn and read new things. My education will be something that made me a better person.


I can totally see myself not working when my boyfriend and I get married. I don't see a job as the thing that defines me. I love the outdoors, reading, animals, volunteering, traveling, my family, my personality- these are the things that define me. I also believe these are the things the define my mother. Her job is just a very small part of her, eventhough it takes a much of her time up.



-- Edited by RyanJ at 19:08, 2006-03-25

__________________
I don’t want no part of your tight-ass country-club, you freak bitch!


Gucci

Status: Offline
Posts: 2818
Date:
Permalink Closed

this is interesting.  when i was in school i studied education, and read a lot of arguments that essentially said a college was essentially created as a finishing school for the upper echelons (sp) of society. and pretty much became a feeder for higher paying/prestigious professions.  as more and more people got wise to the system, they began sending their kids to college. nowadays a college education is pretty much the minimum standard for most jobs.


i think some of the fascination with being a housewife is a reflection of what's going on in our society in that more and more people realize that going to college doesn't really mean that much. (i'm not talking about the the things you *learn* or the overall experience, but just in terms of the idea that if you go to school you will get a high paying job). and for most people you don't actually learn marketable skills in college. (i have a degree from a liberal arts school and can honestly say very few of my "marketable" were learned in the classroom -- not that i regret getting my degree, b/c i don't. but that's just the way it is.)


so in that sense i kind of understand the desire to not work, b/c the whole system can just be very frustrating and seem so worthwhile. you do all this work b/c it's supposed to improve your life, and you still end up in a crappy job that doesn't pay much. and if you're a woman you get double the work, b/c you have to have a 9-5 and then come home and keep house. if those are the only options (and for many people they are) i'd take a rich husband and a life of leisure anyday.


that being said, i want to do more with my life than be some guy's wife (this is an oversimplification of course) so i can't really get down with the whole desperate housewives thing. but i do wish we could go back to the day were we emphasized education for the sake of education, and didn't feed kids this idea that college is supposed to improve your life from a purely monetary perspective.



__________________
www.musingsfromamall.com  (my main blog)
http://musingsfromamallinreallife.wordpress.com/ (my personal style blog)


Hermes

Status: Offline
Posts: 6400
Date:
Permalink Closed

honey wrote:


but i do wish we could go back to the day were we emphasized education for the sake of education, and didn't feed kids this idea that college is supposed to improve your life from a purely monetary perspective.

I totally agree with this. My husband and I actually make less than a lot of people we know who DIDN'T go to college. I tell kids all the time that if the only reason they are going to college is to make more money, then they will be disappointed.  I have never regretted going, because I know that I am a lot smarter and more worldly than I would have been if I didn't go. But I am sure I could earn just as much money without my degree.

__________________
"We live in an age where unnecessary things are our only necessities." --Oscar Wilde
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard