Lilykind, I remember you bought the Madyson leather boots at J.Crew this fall - the tall ones with the pointy toe and kitten heal. Anyway, I have been drooling over them all season, and they are finally up on Ebay. I'm wondering how you found the sizing to run. I usually wear between an 8.5 and a 9. I have a pair of pointy toed flats from J.Crew in a 9 and they are a bit big - they make my feet feel like sailboats! I'm trying to avoid that, but my feet are also a little wide, so I don't want them to be too narrow. How did you find the sizing in your boots to run?
I always wear an 8 in J. Crew. My Madyson boots are an 8 and they fit like a charm.
I wear a 7.5 most of the time and an 8 in companies where the shoes run narrow. In your case, I'd get the 9. Worse comes to worse, you can put some really cushiony padding in to make the shoes more walkable.