I tried on the third pair and it fit me PERFECTLY. The only reason I didn't get it was because I was in a rush and didn't want to wait in the long line at the store. It's more of a wide-legged jean so I don't know if that's the look you're going for. It's also got more of a nautical look going because of the buttons on the back pockets and in the front. That said, I'd go with #1 for the more basic destroyed jean look.
Thanks for all the help ladies! I actually went with a completely different pair (see my post in the Weekday Shopping thread), because they didn't have my size in the last 2 pairs. I had decided that I wanted a wider leg, slouchier look on these, so that's why I also eliminated the first pair.
I still might end up with a more fitted pair of destroyed jeans though