I think you could make #1 work with white metals...some of the other colors in the pattern are cool. I like the handles better on #1 too, though I'm not nuts about the dangly things.
__________________
"We live in an age where unnecessary things are our only necessities." --Oscar Wilde
I like the second one better. I think the print is more fallish and I like the shape better. I don't care for the beads on the first bag. I think you can definitely make the print work with white metals, it's all about how you wear it.
__________________
Fashion your life as a garland of beautiful deeds. -Buddha
From the picture I think the first one would work better with white metals, the second one calls for gold I think. If you're not sure about both color and shape, I think you should look for some other options - you might not carry the bag as much - on the other hand, it might inspire you to experiment! If so, I vote for the first one, it is more unique