I've had success with most of their items, however, their cottony, tee shirt type material does not hold up well at all. It pills and fades after several washings. Also, all thier sweaters are acrylic, so I wouldn't recommend them either.
I have found thier bottoms run about one size big.
I just recently ordered a top from there after having not shopped there in some time. Hopefully I am pleased!
I think the quality is great for the price, but honestly it's the pieces made of unnatural fabric that seem to keep looking good over time. I have things I bought for $5 3-4 years ago that still look good. I have a large chest and things seem to fit me well (or at least, better than other stores) I agree that the bottoms run big. I've never had a problem with their shirts being too short, I don't think.
ETA: if you're going to buy anything, be sure to sign up for their e-mail newsletter. You'll get 20% off coupons all the time. I don't know if I've ever bought anything full price!
-- Edited by ttara123 at 11:56, 2008-08-10
__________________
Fashion is art you live your life in. - Devil Wears Prada | formerly ttara123